The Mitchell Agency

Over 125 Years of Partnering with Our Clients

The Mitchell Agency is an independent property and casualty insurance agency that has been serving clients throughout Indiana and the Midwest since 1885.

Take advantage of over 125 years of experience and dedicated service to help guide you in your next insurance purchase.


Protecting Your Future Today

commercial-tag  Agriculture-tag  personal-tag  life-tag


Food Finders Food Bank, Lafayette, INGrant to Food Finders Food Bank Helps Local Community

Food Finders Food Bank located in Lafayette, IN has been awarded a $5,000 donation through the Liberty Mutual® and Safeco Insurance® Emergency Community Support Grant program.

“This gift from Liberty Mutual and Safeco made possible by the Mitchell Agency will help offset some of the additional cost we have incurred due to the pandemic,” said Katy Bunder, President/CEO of Food Finders Food Bank. “We are very grateful for the Mitchell Agency’s help at this critical time.”  For more details go to Food Finders Receives Grant.

tma-advantage-logoThe Mitchell Agency Advantage

— Trusted Planning Partner
— Top Rated Insurance Companies
— Over 125 years of serving Business and Personal Insurance Needs
— Timely, expeditious response to Client Requests

The Mitchell Agency goal is to become an integral part of our client’s business planning process. To provide insurance coverage that meets their needs and budget while providing readily assessable claims support from an exceptionally experienced team of professionals. Our client retention rate is over 99%.