The Mitchell Agency

2017 Readers' Choice Award for Best Insurance AgencyOver 125 Years of Partnering with Our Clients

The Mitchell Agency is an independent property and casualty insurance agency that has been serving clients throughout Indiana and the Midwest since 1885.

Take advantage of over 125 years of experience and dedicated service to help guide you in your next insurance purchase.


Protecting Your Future Today

commercial-tag  Agriculture-tag  personal-tag  life-tag


Meet Sarah Coghill

Sarah Coghill joined the Mitchell Agency in August as a Commercial Lines producer who works with new and current commercial clients. Sarah is a graduate of Purdue University and has been working in the insurance industry for 3 years.

Sarah commented, “I got into the insurance business because I was looking for a challenging career where I could meet people and get involved in the local community.”  To learn more about the newest member of the Mitchell Agency Team view her profile at The Mitchell Agency Team.