Independent Insurance for Indiana & Beyond Since 1885
Comprehensive Insurance for Clients In Indiana & Beyond
The Mitchell Agency is an independent insurance partner based in Lafayette, IN, specializing in commercial coverage for companies across Tippecanoe County, all of Indiana, and nationwide. We compare options from multiple carriers to fit how you operate, whether you run a single-location retailer, manage a multi-state contractor crew, maintain a regional or national fleet along I-65 and major corridors, or launch new offices across the U.S. We also support families and executives with personal lines when needed, with the same responsive, consultative service.
Why Choose The Mitchell Agency
Choose a clean, classy, professional experience that puts business and personal advice first. Our team brings more than a century of expertise with practical guidance on Indiana and multi-state policies—backed by fast, proactive service as you scale. Whether you’re finalizing a new lease downtown or opening locations across the U.S., adding vehicles to a regional fleet, issuing certificates of insurance and additional insureds for contractors, or hiring your first employees and beyond, The Mitchell Agency keeps coverage coordinated and compliant without the call-center runaround.
Over
125 Years of Partnering with Our Clients
Insurance Services at a Glance
Contractors Insurance
Commercial Insurance
Auto, homeowners, and everything in between for everyday life in Lafayette and West Lafayette.
Commercial Buildings
Agricultural Insurance
Life Insurance
Protect what you’ve built
Proudly Serving Indiana & Counties Across The Nation
Across Indiana—and wherever your operations take you nationwide—The Mitchell Agency understands business at the neighborhood level and at scale. From downtown storefronts near the Wabash Riverfront and vendors supporting Purdue University events to rural operations along US-52 and State Road 26, we tailor coverage to real-world risks. Need a walkthrough in Tippecanoe County, a multi-state policy review, or fast certificates of insurance for out-of-state jobs? We’re close by when it helps, virtual when it’s faster, and ready with quick COIs and clear guidance across Indiana and the U.S.
What Clients Say
★★★★★
James Dicks
Great insurance agency with great staff. We have been with them for 30+ years and fortunately have had very few claims over the years. Recently had a flooding issue from a water heater. They were quick to get adjuster out and process claim quickly. Our agent was quick to intercede when communications with the adjuster stalled. Can’t say enough good things about these folks.
★★★★★
Jill Davis
Wonderful agency! Thomas Gothard went above and beyond to get our small business insured and well taken care of. Amazing customer service! It's refreshing to find an insurance company that truly cares. HIGHLY RECOMMEND!
★★★★★
Robert Hancock
Our business has been using the Mitchell Agency for well over ten years. Their staff is always friendly and extremely easy to work with. Commercial insurance can always be a little confusing, the agents as well as their staff are always willing to spend additional time explaining items. They do a great job making sure your coverage is correct for all aspects of our business. We have since switched all personal insurance policies to them as well. Keep up the great work!
Robert M Hancock..Becks Auto Center
★★★★★
Jennie Kirby
I have used Jackson Bogan and Mitchell Agency off and on for over 8 years and can tell you they are top notch when it comes to detail. Very responsive to requests for certificates and great about following up. I highly recommend them for all your insurance needs.
★★★★★
James Dicks
Great insurance agency with great staff. We have been with them for 30+ years and fortunately have had very few claims over the years. Recently had a flooding issue from a water heater. They were quick to get adjuster out and process claim quickly. Our agent was quick to intercede when communications with the adjuster stalled. Can’t say enough good things about these folks.
★★★★★
Jill Davis
Wonderful agency! Thomas Gothard went above and beyond to get our small business insured and well taken care of. Amazing customer service! It's refreshing to find an insurance company that truly cares. HIGHLY RECOMMEND!
Latest Insights & Resources
Browse practical explainers and guides—small business risk checklists for Indiana and multi-state operations, workers’ comp basics for new employers, and insurance 101 for homeowners across Lafayette, West Lafayette, and the rest of Indiana (with insights that apply nationwide).
